Paul Hall & Associates' Staff Members

Home - Paul Hall & Associates Insurance >> Our Team
Amber Averwater

Amber Averwater

Client Service Associate

Joined in 2023

Marketing and Communications Intern
Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988
I was born and raised in Clermont County. I was in 4-H for 14 years showing Dairy Goats, Pigs, and Beef. During that time I served as the 2021-24 Junior Fair Board President as well as the 2023 Clermont County Fair Queen. While working the livestock sale at the Fair, Paul sought me out and asked me to come interview for a job here at PHA. I graduated in 2022 from Large Animal Science at Grant Career Center. I spend my free time volunteering in 4-H and figuring out how to swing a golf club.
Anissa Cheatham

Anissa Cheatham

Director of Personal Lines

Joined in 2000

CarTemps Manager
Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988 ext. 1102
I was born and raised in Brown County and graduated from Western Brown High School. I come from a large family and I have over 50 nieces and nephews! I have always enjoyed camping when I get the chance to go.
Beckie Tucker

Beckie Tucker

Sales Manager

Joined in 1997

Personal Lines Sales Associate
Georgetown Office

937-378-6146
I have been a Sales Agent 22 years. I married my best friend Donald in 1981 and we have 2 amazing sons and daughter in laws. And 4 awesome Grandbabies. Love spending time with my Family.
Caidee Smith

Caidee Smith

Client Services Associate

Joined in 2022

Distribution Specialist
Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988
I was raised in Hamersville, OH and attended Western Brown High School. I met my husband in high school, and we have been married since 2013. I love spending time with family, fishing, camping and riding our side-by-side. Faith and family are the two most important things in my life.
Crystal Winterod

Crystal Winterod

Personal Lines Claims Manager

Joined in 2021

Personal Lines Claims Specialist
Georgetown Office

937-378-6146
I was born and raised in Georgetown, where I currently reside with my husband Brandon and our two kids Bryce and Sophia. After graduation I attended Southern State Community College where I graduated with an Associates degree in applied Science. I enjoy spending time with my family boating,camping, reading, and crafting.
Jessica Key

Jessica Key

Personal Lines Billing Manager

Joined in 2018

Billing Specialist
Manchester Office

937-549-3659 ext 6103
I am an Adams County resident, having graduated from Manchester High School as well as the Ohio Valley Community Technical Center. I became a 2019 Graduate of Columbia Southern University with a bachelor’s degree. I live with my Army Veteran husband and our daughter. In my youth, I worked on the family farm raising dairy goats, fancy chickens, and fancy rabbits which were my 4-H Projects, as well as working on the road crew for my township. My hobbies include reading, embroidering, baking, working in the yard and teaching my daughter the knowledge my parents taught me.
Jillian Waits

Jillian Waits

Director of Commercial/Farm

Joined in 2011

Commercial/Farm Service Specialist
Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988 ext 1106
I am a 1996 graduate of Eastern High School. I currently reside in Seaman with my husband Terry. Our four children are grown and all on their own now. We are looking forward to the next chapter in our lives becoming grandparents. I love to read and write and hope to someday publish a book or two. We love to travel and plan to see much more of this beautiful world.
Kayla Seigla

Kayla Seigla

Client Services Associate

Joined in 2022

Distribution Specialist
Georgetown Office

937-378-6146
I grew up in Georgetown the oldest of four girls! Sports have always been a passion in our family, and I ended up heading to the University of Toledo on a softball scholarship after graduating from Georgetown High School. An injury sent me back home, and I eventually had my sweet son, Waylen, in 2019. I have been a stay-at-home mom since he was born. I enjoy being a mom, reading, traveling, everything about the holidays, and spending time with my family.
Kelsie Stephenson

Kelsie Stephenson

Farmers Mutual Manager

Joined in 2021

Personal Lines Service Associate
Winchester Office

937.444.2988
I was raised in Adams County, graduated from Manchester High School. I am a mother and wife, we share together three beautiful children, two boys and one girl. Family time and attending our children’s sporting events keep us pretty busy. When we get a free second we love to go ride the Razor with our close friends, or spending time with our fur babies!
Kennedy McWhorter

Kennedy McWhorter

Client Services Associate

Joined in 2022

Distribution Specialist
Winchester Office

937-386-8040
I was born and raised in Highland County. I am a single mom to a wonderful boy who was born in 2018. I attend Bible Baptist Church of West Union. I graduated from Southern State Community College with a certificate in Medical Billing and Coding and my associates in Medical Assisting. I enjoy spending time with family, scrapbooking and reading. My son and I like to spend the weekends exploring the outdoors and looking for new adventures.
Kristen McMullen

Kristen McMullen

Client Services Associate

Joined in 2023


Blanchester Office

937-783-5980
I am a lifelong resident of Blanchester. My husband and I both graduated from Blanchester High School in 2003. We have two energetic boys, Brayden and Corbin. I had a 19 year career in the auto body industry before making the switch over to insurance. As a family, we enjoy sports with our boys, camping, and going on off-road trips.
Lara Staples Borchers

Lara Staples Borchers

Digital Media Manager

Joined in 2014

Digital Media Manager


513-967-5904
I was born and raised a Buckeye and graduated from The Ohio State University with a degree in Animal Science and minor in Agricultural Communications. Through my participation in 4-H and FFA, I was given many opportunities at the state and national levels including the role of 2010-2011 Ohio FFA Vice President and the 2011 Ohio Fairs’ Queen. Paul offered me my first job after college as a Farm Sales Associate in 2014. Since then, I have maintained my property and casualty insurance license, but continued to build on my marketing and communications skills. Now, I serve the agency as Digital Media Manager. My husband, Ryan, and our three children, Zeke, Nora and Elly, reside in London, Ohio.
Leslie Valle

Leslie Valle

Commercial/Farm Service Associate

Joined in 2022

Commercial/Farm Service Specialist
Winchester Office

937-444-2988
Lexie Bunn

Lexie Bunn

Commercial/Farm Service Associate

Joined in 2019

Commercial/Farm Service Specialist
Winchester Office

937-444-2988
I was raised in Adams County, more specifically Winchester. I have 3 brothers and multiple cousins, so I always had someone to play with as a kid. I graduated from North Adams High School in 2017. While in high school I received an associates degree in science from Southern State Community College. After high school I attended The Ohio State University Agricultural Technical Institute (ATI) and received an associates degree in animal science specializing in swine production and management. I was an active member in 4-H for 11 years and many other clubs/sports teams while in high school. I love anything Disney related, I have even been to Walt Disney World every year since I was 2 years old!
Lillian McConnaughey

Lillian McConnaughey

Director of Epic

Joined in 2015

Personal Lines Service Associate
Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988 ext. 1101
I am a Highland County resident, grew up outside of Buford. I graduated from Lynchburg-Clay H.S. and received my associate's degree from UC Clermont. I volunteer in the children’s department at Clear Mountain Community Church in Williamsburg. My husband, Jason, and I reside in Danville, and we have a 2 year old son, Gatlin. When we are not working, we love spending time with our families - we both come from big families, Jason has 5 siblings, and I have 13. Spending our weekends camping at Rocky Fork Lake is also a family (and extended family) favorite.
Lynn Fee

Lynn Fee

Painless Tax Director

Joined in 2000

Account Renewal Specialist
Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988 ext. 1107
In 2009, I graduated from the University of Cincinnati, along with my son. We walked side by side during the commencement ceremony. That was a proud moment. Since then, I have become a grandma to 5 very energetic grandchildren 3 girls and 2 boys. I have been married to Bill for over 35 years and we are very active in our church and with our children and grandchildren. In my spare time, I love to play the guitar, baking and traveling.
Melissa Campbell

Melissa Campbell

Client Service Associate

Joined in 2022

Client Service Associate
Harrison Office

(513) 367-7000
Originally from Speedway, IN, I moved to Lawarencburg, IN in 2014 as my husband relocated for his job. I have been married for 20 years and have 3 rambunctious boys. I enjoy arts and crafts and meeting new people. On the weekends, you can find me at the baseball or football field cheering on my youngest son. I look forward to meeting everyone and continuing to build upon my career.
Melissa Speakman

Melissa Speakman

Director of Retention

Joined in 1998

Account Renewal Specialist
Blanchester Office

937-783-5980 ext. 2101
I married my husband, Chris, in 1995. We have 3 children and we are Papa and Mimi to 2 amazing little boys. Growing up, I was very active in 4-H, which continued with all of our children. Now, I enjoy spending time with family, camping and baking.
Paige Redmon

Paige Redmon

Personal Lines Sales Associate

Joined in 2016

Personal Lines Sales Specialist/Toys
Manchester Office

937-549-3659 ext. 6101
I moved to Adams County when I was 5 and lived here most of my life. I started working for my Mom, Kay Wilson Grooms, at Wilson’s Insurance Agency in 1989. This was a family owned business my grandfather Keith Wilson started in 1952. In January of 2000, with my business partner Jackie A Fite we purchased the Agency. We had a very successful 16 years. In November 2016, we sold to Paul Hall & Associates. I married my best friend Ray in 2001. We have 4 children Heather, Josh, Devin, and Jalyn . They have blessed us with 7 grandchildren Shelby, Xander, Kyndall, Kyzer, Jaycee, Easton, and Oakley. We are expecting our 8th grandchild in November and it is a girl and her name is Navy. We have our Boston Terrier Indy. In our spare time we enjoy spending time with our family/friends, riding Harley’s and boating at Lake Norris.
Sarah Burdsall

Sarah Burdsall

Book Roll Manager

Joined 2021

Personal Lines Service Specialist
Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988
I am a lifelong resident of Clermont County, and graduated from Clermont Northeastern High School in 2003 and Wright State University in 2008 with a Bachelor of Music. I am married to my best friend, Chris, and we have two boys, Will and Isaac. We are very involved with our church, Old Path Missionary Baptist in Sardinia. Our boys are also involved in 4-H. In my spare time I love reading and playing piano. I have worked in education, healthcare, and now insurance, but I have been people oriented since my first job at 15. I look forward to the opportunity to further serve my community.
Sharon Hughes

Sharon Hughes

Client Service Associate

Joined in 1992

Client Service Associate
Georgetown Office

937-378-6146
I started working in insurance 1992. I am married to Wayne and we have 2 children and 2 grandchildren. I am active in my church and teach Sunday School to the pre-school and kindergarten class. I like to spending time with family and watching our grandkids play ball.
Stephanie Thorne

Stephanie Thorne

Distribution Manager

Joined in 2021

Personal Lines Service Associate
Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988
I grew a daughter of a Marine. We moved all over the United States while I was a child. I was able to live in California, North Carolina, Indiana, and Hawaii. Once my father retired, I followed my parents and siblings here to Ohio in August 2006. I am an active member of The Christian Church of Higginsport. I am a proud mother of 2. My son has carried on the family tradition and joined the Marines in August 2022. “The world is a book, those who do not travel read just one page.” -St. Augustine
Stephanie Meyer

Stephanie Meyer

Sales Support Manager

Joined in 2012

Account Renewal Specialist
Georgetown Office

937-378-6146 ext. 3101
Born and raised in Georgetown, Ohio, I am an active member of the Georgetown Church of Christ participating in worship teams and coaching in the Upward program. I married my husband, Tyler, in 2014, and we welcomed our miracle baby Theodore Scott in January 2023. I enjoy hunting, four-wheeling and spending time outdoors with family.
Bob Hare

Bob Hare

Field Underwriter

Joined in 2012

Field Inspector



I worked at Proctor & Gamble for 30 years. While there, I worked in the bar soap division for 15 years and I have 2 patents on bars; one for Ivory Moisture Care Bar and one for Oil of Olay Bar. I recently started a youth football organization and currently have about 85 active players. I judge livestock shows all over the U.S. and have judged in about 25 states.
Todd Richter

Todd Richter

Property Manager

Joined in 2016

Field Inspector and Office Property Management



Growing up I was either on a ball field, basketball court, or sitting in a tree stand. By the time high school was over I had offers to play division 1 baseball, division 1 football, or division 2 basketball. I had several offers to play two sports. Life however had different plans for me. I was drafted by the Atlanta Braves after my sophomore year of college, at the same time my wife was expecting our second child. I knew that came with great responsibility. Traveling the country playing baseball or raising a family. To me it was a no-brainer, raise a family. I put my head down and went to work for the next 20 years. I'm proud to say I'm still married to my high school sweetheart, Dena. Ashleigh is now a junior in college and my son Brandon is doing well living in Milford. I now work with Paul Hall and associate's as property caretaker given me the chance to travel, watching my daughter play college soccer.
Eric Nethero

Eric Nethero

Sales Associate

Joined in 2004

Field Sales Associate


513-260-2248
I joined Paul Hall and Associates as a high school student back in 2004. After graduating from the University of Cincinnati, I moved into a sales associate position. Outside of insurance, you will likely find me behind the wheel of a firetruck or a tractor. I also serve as a member to several local organizations, including, Brown County Pork Producers Association, Brown County Farm Bureau and Brown County Senior Fairboard. When I am not working or volunteering, I love to travel with my wife, Lori.
Mariah Votel

Mariah Votel

AdWorks Supervisor

Joined in 2010


Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988
I love my God, my family and my country. I grew up in Brown County, and am a 1992 graduate of Georgetown High School. I met my husband, Michael, while working in northern Kentucky and eventually got him back to the right side of the river. We have three children and a daughter in law who have all graduated from Western Brown High School, Tyler his wife Chelsi, Justin and Reagan. I am a member of the Brown County Board of Elections and former Chairman of the Brown County Republican Party. I also enjoy helping business owners and civic groups find the right promotional products to promote themselves through our company Ad Works.
Anna Hall Stroud

Anna Hall Stroud

Chief Executive Officer (CEO)

Joined in 2012

Commercial/Farm Sales Associate
Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988
I was raised to bleed blue for UK, but ended up as an Ohio State Buckeye! I still enjoy going back to Columbus to support my Buckeyes whenever I have a chance. I came back home to work with dad writing insurance and doing marketing for the agency. Working with my family has truly been a blessing. I was married in August of 2016 to my best friend, Andrew Stroud. We welcomed our first daughter, Emily, into our family in August of 2018. Our second daughter, Elaina, was born in January of 2021. Our third daughter, Audrey, was most recently welcomed in August 2022. I grew up very active in 4-H and FFA, and even served as a State FFA Officer. Those organizations did so much for me, so I like to now give back by helping judge FFA and 4-H speaking contests as well as help prepare members for contests.
Caroline Hall Hennig

Caroline Hall Hennig

President

Joined in 2009

Sales Associate
Harrison Office

513-367-7000
I am the first of three daughters to Paul and Jill Hall. I was raised being very involved in church, community events and the 4-H and FFA programs. I graduated with honors from The University of Kentucky with a Bachelor of Science in Agriculture Economics and a Bachelor of Administration in Marketing. I married Sam Hennig in July of 2009. In 2010, upon being given the opportunity to build and grow an insurance agency in Harrison, we relocated from Brown County to Harrison. While working to grow the agency in Harrison, I am also involved with Lifespring Christian Church. In addition to work and church I am involved with the Hamilton County and Dearborn County 4-H programs and try to give back to these wonderful programs for helping shape me. In March of 2017, we welcome our daughter Lacey and in March 2020 we completed our family with the birth of our son Levi.
Justin Holbrook

Justin Holbrook

Senior Vice President of Sales

Joined in 2004

Commercial/Farm Sales Specialist
Blanchester Office

937-783-5980 ext. 2103
I am a Clinton County resident having graduated from Blanchester High School and Wilmington College. As an advocate for youth, I’m a long-time volunteer for the Clinton County 4-H Program and actively support the Poultry and Sales Committees. When I’m not busy writing insurance for our clients, I enjoy traveling to the National Parks with my wife Leslie. Our son Carter was born in 2017, and we can’t wait to share our adventures and the beauty of the United States with him.
Linda Sawyers

Linda Sawyers

Senior Vice President of Operations

Joined in 1997

Life & Health Specialist
Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988 ext. 1105
Growing up, my parents raised my four siblings and me to be involved in our church, St. Mary in Arnheim, and the activities in our local American Legion Post 755 in Sardinia. They worked to instill a service mentality that has resonated through my life. This has served me well as I get to do what I do best – serve our members at Paul Hall & Associates. I’m a lifetime member of the American Legion Auxillary. My hobbies include scrapbooking and photography.
Marcus Day

Marcus Day

Chief Financial Officer (CFO)

Joined in 2020

Financial/HR Officer
Mt Orab Office

937-444-2988
Marcus is a native of Russellville, OH. He graduated from Eastern HS in 2016 and was Salutatorian of his class. Marcus graduated from the University of Mount Union in Alliance, OH with a BA in Accounting and a minor in German. He was also a 2-sport athlete in basketball and track all 4 years at Mount Union. Marcus has returned home and is helping with the family’s Day Angus Farms cattle operation. He is a member of St. Mary’s Catholic Church in Arnheim. Marcus also enjoys spending time creating wood working projects, spending time outdoors and focusing on a healthy and active lifestyle. He is excited to begin his career as a member of the Paul Hall family and learn about the insurance industry while serving the members of Brown County and the surrounding area.
Paul Hall

Paul Hall

Founder, Past CEO

1988 - 2023





Paul moved to Brown County in 1988 and established Paul Hall & Associates Insurance. He built an agency working to serve rural Ohio and Kentucky as well as building a staff committed to serving and giving back. Paul served as President, Founder and CEO of the company until February of 2023. He was able to personally pass the torch to his leadership team several weeks before his time here on earth ended.


Paul lived a life supporting and loving others, serving our Lord God and building a legacy amongst family, staff and friends. His impact on this world was great. His legacy will continue on through his team at the agency and his foundation. Paul Hall & Associates Insurance will always remember our founder and leader as we continue to strive for a level of excellence he showed each and every one of us.